KOSOVO
Developing Mediation Services in a Post-Violent Environment
The Kosovar war and NATO intervention followed many years of violence
in the province. The Kanuni i Leke Dugagjinit, a code predating
the Magna Charta, provides a range of prescriptions for civic behavior
and community life, including regulating a form of third-party conflict
resolution and the so-called blood feuds1. Throughout
the 1980s and 1990s, Reconciliation Councils resolved blood feuds
and other conflicts in the province, providing Kosovar Albanians
with an alternative to courts, which whey did not perceive as neutral
or fair (the model of third-party intervention used in these contexts
was similar to arbitration). Though these mechanisms are valuable,
inter- and intra-group violence involving Serbs and Kosovar Albanians,
as well as other forms of violence, persist after the war.
This unique, immediately post-violent situation presented a new
challenge for Partners. In response to the province’s needs,
Partners founded Partners-Kosovo in spring 2001 and established
a community-based mediation service to resolve local disputes and
assist in stabilizing the province. To work within this difficult
environment, Partners employed practitioners from its international
network of Centers to build the capacity of Partners-Kosovo through
transferring skills from Bulgaria, Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland
and Slovakia. The trainers worked with Partners-Kosovo staff to
assess the province’s situation vis-à-vis post-traumatic
stress syndrome, human rights violations, and the community-wide
impact of conflict.
A critical aspect of designing the service was the assessment of
the local culture and its receptivity for mediation. Mediation empowers
disputants to generate their own settlements, thereby overcoming
assumptions and stereotypes, and working to build and preserve relationships.
Partners found that a “modern” mediation service could
in fact complement existing local tradition and institutions, and
fill a much-needed gap. Partners thus assessed its role as a cooperative
one in which it has taken the old Kosovar conflict resolution structures,
which remain trusted and respected, and infused them with modern
mediation concepts that focus on the disputants rather than the
conflict resolver. In so doing, Partners has built extensive networks
to share cases and information, and begun to coalesce and modernize
disparate conflict resolution energies across the province.
In the year since founding, Partners-Kosovo and its network of
trained mediators have helped settle 50 disputes, including neighborhood,
property, family, business, employment, minor criminal cases and
blood feuds. As the court system is relatively under-developed and
unfamiliar to citizens, and with the strong local tradition for
alternative dispute resolution structures, the need for Partners-Kosovo’s
work is only growing. The following case is illustrative of the
violence that has been mitigated through the service:
A minor disagreement in a bar-cafe in Mitrovica in July 2002 escalated
into a physical confrontation between Parties A1 and A2 (who are
friends) and Party B. B was briefly hospitalized as a result of
the injuries he sustained during the brawl, and A1 and A2 were sentenced
to time in jail for their role in the incident. Upon release, A1
came to Partners-Kosovo because he claimed that B and his family
were threatening to kill A1, A1's family members, and A2. In total,
about 60 members of the two extended families were affected by these
threats. A1 had tried to reconcile with B, but had been unsuccessful.
Partners-Kosovo mediators were able to convene the parties to discuss
the conflict, and Party B eventually retracted his threats against
both A1 and A2 and their families.
This case is typical for several reasons: (1) minor disputes often
escalate to violence very quickly in Kosovo, (2) many cases involve
threats against large extended families, thus impacting large numbers
of people, (3) many people do not trust the state enough to allow
it to be the exclusive arbiter of justice--therefore, families often
still desire revenge in order to protect their honor, even if jail
time was sentenced and served.
Partners is working to make the Center’s mediation service
an integral part of the development of rule of law in Kosovo, by
addressing issues and emotions that courts cannot handle, providing
people with an alternative to a decision between the courts or vigilante
justice, and creating space for the development of a respect for
the official justice system over time. By infusing existing tradition
with modern ideas, Partners has created a distinctly Kosovar model
for mediation that is mitigating violence in the province and working
to build a lasting peace.
Additional Resources
1) Brochure
for Mediation Service from Partners-Kosovo (Microsoft Word Document)
2) Article
by Partners for Democratic Change on "Building Cooperative
Peace in Response to Violence in Emerging Democracies"
(Microsoft Word Document)
|