ARGENTINA
Citizens Curb Neighborhood Violence & Impact Public Policy
Following the murder of a young child in 1998 in Castelar, the
largest city in Morón County, Buenos Aires Province, citizens
spontaneously mobilized to address the need for improved public
safety. Communities established informal security forums, and soon
thereafter the government institutionalized the forums in Public
Security Provincial Act 12154, which led to the creation of 322
of these forums throughout the Province. But because forum participants
and public officials lacked the essential skills to set up, manage,
and utilize the forums, they proved to be ineffectual.
In response, in September 2000, Partners-Argentina began working
with the South Castelar Forum on a cooperative planning process
to improve public safety. First, Partners-Argentina trained members
of South Castelar and other forums in constructive dialogue, managing
conflict, teamwork, and cooperative planning. Partners-Argentina
worked with the members to organize their activities, address power
imbalances within the forum, build a budget and raise funds, and
hear testimony from crime victims. Through these efforts, the forums
began to develop the skills necessary to identify challenges, propose
successful responses and ultimately expand their capacity to improve
public safety.
Following these leadership and skills trainings, Partners-Argentina
convened leaders from seven forums in Morón County, provincial
and municipal leaders, district attorneys, the Legislature of Buenos
Aires Province, local NGOs, and police officers in a series of cooperative
planning sessions. These meetings analyzed the implementation of
Act 12154, identifying challenges and appropriate community responses.
Meanwhile, the Municipality launched a potentially competing public
safety project, called the Community Crime Prevention Plan, which
proposed to circumvent the forums by working directly with citizens.
Partners-Argentina’s sessions thus took on an added urgency,
and identified cooperative approaches to public safety that integrated
the forums with the Municipality’s new plan. In addition,
a major breakthrough occurred when the Municipality appointed a
South Castelar Forum member, Juan Carlos Martinez, as Morón’s
new Director of Public Safety; this development greatly facilitated
collaboration between the Municipality and the Forums during the
sessions.
Based on this collaborative work, Partners-Argentina assessed the
implementation of Act 12154 and developed recommendations for improved
legislation. In September 2001, Partners-Argentina’s Director,
Gachi Tapia, presented a draft document at a Conference organized
by the Morón Municipality. The Conference discussions focused
on multi-disciplinary strategies to integrate the Forums and the
Municipality’s Community Crime Prevention Plan, and how P-Argentina’s
methodology advanced this goal. The feedback gathered from this
Conference was incorporated into a revised version of the policy
recommendations. In November 2001, Partners-Argentina made the official
presentation of the policy recommendations at a public event at
the Legislative Palace of Buenos Aires Province. Participants included
the Ministry of Security of Buenos Aires Province, the Mayor of
Morón, the Secretary of Security of Morón, Secretary
of Public Relations, representatives of the security forums, legislators,
NGOs and the general public.
Partners-Argentina incorporated feedback from these stakeholders
into the final version of the policy recommendations, which has
been disseminated among public officials, the forums, schools, media
outlets, and other NGOs. The recommendations include identifying
and involving stakeholders, implementing public education campaigns
to increase community involvement, strengthening relations between
communities and government officials, and providing organizational
information on running the forums. Partners-Argentina’s recommendations
also offer judicial reforms to promote crime prevention and public
safety proposals, including alcohol abuse clinics, treatment for
behavioral dysfunctions, and services for at-risk youth, that will
combat the root causes of crime.
Through Partners-Argentina's initiative, relations between forum
members and local police have improved, and citizens feel they have
a safe place to report crimes without fear of retaliation. Many
of the consensus-building skills developed in the forums will be
used to implement community policing, substance abuse clinics, community-wide
recreational activities, foster care services, and other proposed
initiatives. Further, based on Partners-Argentina’s recommendations,
the Morón Municipality has initiated the integration of the
two public security programs, and newly elected members of the Provincial
Legislature organized a Security Commission in which Forum members
closely collaborate with policymakers and promote citizen participation
in public policy implementation. The community-wide benefits of
Partners-Argentina’s work were demonstrated in the 2001-2
turmoil in Argentina, during which Morón remained one of
the few non-violent counties in the Province of Buenos Aires.
Additional Resources
1) Partners-Argentina's
Public Safety Policy Recommendations
2) Press
Release Announcing Partners-Argentina's Presentation of Legislative
Recommendations for Public Safety
|